Cowper, William, 1731-1800

William Cowper (pronounced 'Cooper'), one of the great pastoral and lyrical poets of the pre-'Romantic' era, was born on November 15, 1731, at Great Berkhamstead Rectory, Hertfordshire. His father, the Rev. John Cowper, was the son of a judge and the nephew of the first Earl Cowper. Cowper's mother, Ann (née Donne), who traced her descent through to Henry III, died shortly after childbirth in 1737, leaving a newly born child, John. His father remarried in 1741. As many recent biographers have suggested, it was probably Cowper's inability to come to terms with the loss of his mother that led to severe depression in later life and the despairing sense of isolation and wretchedness in his writing. Cowper had five bouts of depression in 1753, 1763, 1773, 1787, and 1794.

A sensitive, hypochondriac, and motherless infant, Cowper attended in 1737-9 Rev. William Pittman's school in Markyate Street, Bedfordshire, where he was bullied. After undergoing treatment on his eyes at an oculist's Cowper entered Westminster, the school of Cowley and Prior, in April 1742. His father intended William to emulate the career of his namesake relation, the first Lord Chancellor of Great Britain;! instead, Rev. Cowper begot a poet. Cowper entered the Middle Temple in April 1748 and was articled for three years with a solicitor, Mr. Chapman (his fellow clerk was Edward Thurlow, the future Lord Chancellor). He spent much time with his Uncle Ashley and his two elder daughters, Harriot and Theadora. Cowper fell deeply in love with Theadora (the "Delia" of his amorous verse), but Ashley forbade marriage (they parted in 1755). Cowper entered the Middle Temple in 1753 and joined the Nonsense Club, comprising six other Old Westminsters, including George Colman the Elder, Robert Lloyd, and Bonnell Thornton. He wrote jeux d'esprits; contributed satirical essays to the Connoisseur; joined his brother in translating two books of Voltaire's Henriade; and assisted the Duncombes in a translation of Horace.

In 1763, on the point of securing a position in the House of Lords, Cowper suffered a mental breakdown that shattered his metropolitan life. He became frantic with apprehension when asked to appear before the House of Lords as nominee for the post of Clerk of the Journals (arranged by his uncle, Ashley). Cowper's spirits had sunk following the separation from Theadora and the deaths of his father (1756) and the drowning of Sir William Russell, his best friend (1757). He experienced delusions and attempted suicide in November and December 1763 as vividly related in his Memoir (c. 1767, published 1816), which recalls Bunyan's Grace Abounding (1666). His sense of failure crystallised into a deeply held belief in his own inevitable damnation, and he wrote terrifying Sapphics in the style of Isaac Watts:

 

Man disavows, and Deity disowns me:

Hell might afford my miseries a shelter;

Therefore hell keeps her ever hungry mouths all

 

Bolted against me.

Out of his mind, Cowper recovered between December 1763 and June 1765 at Dr. Nathaniel Cotton's Collegium Insanorum in St. Albans, where he was reborn to Evangelical religion. He then took lodgings in Huntingdon, moving after three months into the home of the Evangelical Unwin family. For the rest of his life, Cowper was dependent on friends and relatives for an income. Mr. Unwin died in 1767, whereupon his widow, Mary Unwin (1724-96), accepted an invitation from the Evangelical reformed slave-trader Rev. John Newton to reside in his parish of Olney, Buckinghamshire, where she moved with Cowper on September 14, 1767 (installed at 'Orchard Side' by February 1768). A positive commitment to poetry began when an opportunity arose with Newton's proposal to help compose hymns for his prayer meetings in 1771. The Olney Hymns (1779) -- today among the most familiar of eighteenth-century lyrics and matchless examples of English hymnody -- contained 282 hymns (66, for instance 'O for a closer walk with God', composed by Cowper). Cowper's melancholy and spiritual qualms soon returned after his brother's death in 1770, whereupon he wrote Adelphi, his spiritual autobiography and tale of a misspent youth.

Cowper now lived a sedentary life away from the bustle of London. In 1773, thoughts of marriage with Mary Unwin failed when Cowper relapsed into depression (perhaps induced by the onerous task of writing so many hymns). He temporarily moved into Newton's care at the vicarage until May 1774. After returning to! Orchard Side, Cowper's pleasures consisted of taming hares, carpentry, and working in his garden and greenhouse. A letter from 1785 relates a momentous dream Cowper had in February 1773 in which the terrible words, Actum est de te, periisti ('It is all over with you, thou hast perished'), were pronounced to him. Somehow, Cowper reached the conclusion that God had commanded his suicide; his failure to do so was unforgivable disobedience, for which God rejected him. After 1773, he neither attended Church services nor contributed to Newton's hymns. Prayer was of no avail: he no longer existed for God (he discusses the 'riddle' of a Calvinist thinking himself Elect but 'lost' in a letter to Newton of May 10, 1780).

A calmer period began when Newton left for another parish in 1780. Cowper then began the set of eight 'moral satires' written in couplets which were published with several shorter poems as Poems by William Cowper of the Inner Temple, Esq. (1782). Here, Cowper attacks institutions and practices such as slavery; schools and universities; the Grand Tour (like Pope's Dunciad); card playing and dancing; sentimental novelists; and the hoodwinking clergy. The volume resounds with George Whitfield's Calvinist faith. Cowper wrote these poems mainly, as he told Newton, 'in hopes to do good' by criticising the manners of his society. Although different in tone, Cowper's Poems had many of the aspirations and techniques of Pope's Essay on Man (1733-4). Cowper failed to equal their grace and style, however, refusing to abandon the 'familiar style' that he admired in Matthew Prior. Though it received plaudits from Benjamin Franklin, the Poems was not critically successful. The same year, Cowper wrote 'The Diverting History of John Gilpin', a comic adaptation of the popular street ballad, and in 1783-4 his best-known long poem, The Task (published July 1785), both subjects suggested by his new friend and neighbour Lady Austen (whom he met in 1781). The Task was Cowper's response to her suggestion to write, in blank verse, about his sofa. Her influence helped Cowper to move on from didactic verse to the lyrical, satirical, and descriptive, and mock-heroic poetry (e.g. 'The Colubriad'), where he shone. The poem begins with the mock-heroic opening, 'I sing the sofa', and contains just over 5000 lines of poetry covering six books; he proceeded on the fashionable principle of association (what Coleridge called Cowper's 'divine chit-chat').

The Task advocates the delights of a retired life; describes the poet's own quest for peace ('I was a stricken deer, that left the herd'); and puts forward the pleasures of gardening, winter evenings by the fire, and so forth. The philosophical satire of The Task comes from Horace, perfected, in Cowper's view, by Prior. Rural retreat out of the busy world provided a platform from which Cowper satirised the evils and follies of his age. In The Late Augustans (1958), Donald Davie states that we go to Cowper 'for the fullest image in poetry of the public life of his times'.

The poem's ethical passages condemn slavery, the British Empire in India, blood sports, and cards. In The Task and his translations of Homer in the 1780s and '90s, Cowper attempted to revive the magic of Milton's blank verse. He also admired Prior's experiments in language. Cowper esteemed Pope in his youth, but later regarded his own poetry as a retreat back to the Miltonic wilderness in opposition to Pope's 'oily smoothness' and evasion of 'a manly rough line'. His chief complaint against Pope is that he made poetry a 'mere mechanic art'. Cowper associated Pope and the sparkle of smooth versification with the modish world he left behind in 1763. Cowper was irritated in 1779 when he had first read Johnson's treatment of Prior and Milton; he took exception to Johnson's disdain for blank verse, which he believed was the only form in English able to convey the inspired simplicity of Homer. He strongly identified with the 'poet-priest' calling of Milton, deliberately abandoning the heroic couplets of Pope and others to revert to the verse form of Paradise Lost (1667-74).

The Task is a pot-pourri of genres: topographical poetry, familiar epistle, devotional verse, moral satire, parody, Georgic, and mock-Miltonic verse. It brought Cowper widespread critical acclaim from contemporaries such as Robert Burns. The poem's descriptions of nature and emotional pitch resonated and found fuller expression in Wordsworth's autobiographical The Prelude (1850). The easy, conversational style that Wordsworth and Coleridge adopted for the Lyrical Ballads found its exemplar in The Task. In November 1786, Cowper moved to nearby Weston Underwood. Here he wrote many poems, published posthumously -- including the powerful (but unfinished) 'Yardley Oak' and 'The Poplar Field' -- and began his translation of Homer in the autumn of 1784. The Iliad was finished on September 23 1788; Cowper began translating the Odyssey (currently the standard Everyman edition) the next day. Published in 1791 in blank verse -- Cowper felt that Pope had tied 'bells of rhyme' about Homer's neck -- Cowper's Homer was the only book to bring him a significant financial return (though indifferent critical applause). Joseph Johnson next invited Cowper to undertake an edition of Milton, with illustrations by Henry Fuseli (who assisted with Cowper's revisions of Homer, finished in March 1799), but Cowper's deepening depression impeded significant progress before he died.

From late 1787 (following a bout of depression), Cowper's accomplished letters abound with apologies for delays in responding and complaints about his arduous life as a translator. A skilled balladist, Cowper also wrote under commission several antislavery ballads in 1788 (e.g. 'The Negro's Complaint'). He continued to write occasional ve! rse but was increasingly absorbed in translation. In April 1794, he received an annual royal pension of £300 through the pains of William Hayley, Cowper's first biographer. Mary Unwin's health deteriorated at the end of 1791. In 1793, Cowper wrote the moving stanzas, 'To Mary', commemorating his affection. In 1795, she and Cowper moved to Norfolk and settled at his cousin John Johnson's house in East Dereham in October 1796. After Mrs. Unwin's death in December, Cowper fell into a profound depression with no respite. He wrote 'Montes Glaciales' and 'The Cast-away', his finest lyric poem, during March 1799. The latter, published in 1803-4, compares the drowning of a sailor to Cowper's insuperable despair and intermittent insanity. Its narrator offers a striking comparison between the 'wretch' and himself:

No voice divine the storm allay'd [..],

 

We perish'd, each alone: But I beneath a rougher sea,

 

And whelm'd in deeper gulphs than he.

The poem reveals Cowper's spiritual desolation: God is absent; the self has abandoned God. Cowper here identifies not only with Anson's matelot but also with the woeful Homeric Ulysses, battling with the Fates. Cowper died on 25 April 1800 and was buried next to Mary Unwin in East Dereham Church.

From the end of the eighteenth century to nearly the middle of the nineteenth, William Cowper was probably the most widely read poet in England. Writers as diverse as Austen, Blake, Burns, Clare, Coleridge, Macaulay, Southey, and Wordsworth admired Cowper, and during the 'Romantic period', Cowper's verse was seen to have been audaciously original and critical in bringing new subject matter into poetry. His influence on the early Romantics was very powerful. Coleridge identified Cowper and William Bowles as the first poets 'who combined natural thought with natural diction; the first who reconciled the heart with the head'. Recognising the novelty of Cowper's work, the critic Francis Jeffrey remarked in 1811 that Cowper had attained his popular position by setting 'at defiance all the imaginary requisites of poetical diction and classical imagery -- dignity of style, and politeness of phraseology', and venturing to write with 'force and freedom', using 'natural phrases and natural images'.

James King's illuminating critical biography (1986) shows how Cowper's influence on Romanticism lies also in his treatment of the sublime. Whereas the poets of mid-century, such as Gray and Collins, were concerned with the 'rhetorical sublime', Cowper was interested in the 'religious sublime', evoking poetry of true compassion and emotion from ordinary subject matter. His Milton was the poet of Paradise Lost who generated sublime feelings in describing a multiplicity of circumstances. Cowper's willingness in h! is poetry to sublimate his own retiring life helped to legitimise Wordsworth's recreation of the intensely felt 'spots of time' from his childhood and adolescence. King rightly says that Cowper's attempt to redefine the heroic sublime of Homer at variance with Pope's is an important contribution to aesthetics. Cowper's language is largely free from the 'poetic diction' that marked the school of Pope. Without Cowper's example, then, Romanticism might have taken a different course, or toiled harder to authenticate its artistic credentials.

Throughout the nineteenth century, there were numerous new editions of Cowper's poetry and (after 1803) letters. Norma Russell's Bibliography lists over a hundred editions of his poems in Britain, and almost fifty in America between 1782 and 1837, the year Southey completed the Life and Works of Cowper. John Clare acknowledged Cowper as an influence on his political verse: 'Byron's calling Cowper no poet is the best literary hoax I ever heard of', he recorded in 1821. Yet, Cowper soon after lost ground with more sophisticated readers, which he was to regain to some extent in the Victorian period (he was ever popular with the 'religious classes'). From the 1840s until the late 1970s, interest in Cowper's poetry was largely restricted to specialist scholars and the practicing Christians who sang his hymns in church, usually with no awareness of his name. Despite falling into obscurity duri! ng the nineteenth century, his writings have recently come to occupy a key position in the English literary canon. Almost all of the anthologies of eighteenth century and Romantic literature published in the last twenty years have included significant selections from Cowper's poetry. Recent scholarly editions of his essays, letters, and translations are legion. There is also a growing critical interest in his work and life, with book-length studies by Bill Hutchings (1983), Vincent Newey (1982), and Martin Priestman (1983); and important discussions by critics such as Marshall Brown (1991) and Tim Fulford (1996) that link his work to key currents in the development of Romanticism.

Despite the 'death of the author', proclaimed by some literary theorists, it is clear that criticism of Coleridge at least is flourishing to judge by the several single-author studies that have appeared within the last decade -- and authorship remains a basic tenet of critical practice. Cowper has intrigued biographers, literary critics, psychoanalysts, and hymnologists. Nonetheless, he is still one of the most neglected poets of the period possibly perhaps because his poetry has always seemed univocal and less complex than that of the Augustans. Cowper is not championed from the standpoint of such radical theoretical perspectives as Marxism, feminism, and various forms of post-structuralism. D.J. Enright's essay on Cowper in the Pelican Guide to English Literature (1957) -- typical of the critical disregard for Cowper and the belief that he was a lesser Romantic poet -- adjudged him one of England's 'most pleasant and most individual of our minor poets'. Such observations and judgments give a misleading impression of an undemanding and undistinguished poet, however.

George M. Ella's study (1993) notes that around forty-five detailed biographies of Cowper have appeared since 1800. Indeed, the twentieth century was more ! interested in Cowper's biography and psychosis than in Cowper the poet. Biography burgeoned under the momentum of argument over the causes of Cowper's madness, prompted by the Anglican press's assertion that Cowper's malady was a terrible warning against the consequences of Calvinism (e.g. Sydney Smith's articles on 'Methodism' in The Edinburgh Review). Successive writers have debated the rapport between Cowper's religion and poetical inspiration. This polemic and impulse to 'biographise' Cowper has diverted attention from his specifically literary accomplishments, however. Hugh l'Anson Fausset (1928) and Lord David Cecil (1929) argued that Calvinism deformed his talent and drove him to madness, while Norman Nicholson (1951) held that his religious experiences 'lifted him like a love affair above day-to-day monotony', pointing out that Cowper's 'madness' predated his contact with the Evangelical revival. Like Gilbert Thomas (1948), Nicholson argued that Evangelicism was the catalyst that released his latent sympathy with Man and Nature. Fausset's work ushered in a wave of psychological speculations about Cowper's writings and personality. Morris Golden's psycho-dramatic In Search of Stability (1960), while stressing the universality of Cowper's simultaneous yearnings for solitude and society, and freedom and authority, failed to reveal precisely how Cowper's preoccupations were artistically expressed.

Although his influence on the Romantics is indubitable, Cowper's poems have deservedly enjoyed other readings. Critics point out that Cowper did not subscribe to the cult of the Noble Savage; nor was he a pantheist. Cowper has been called everything from a 'leader' in the 'poetic revival of 1760-1820' -- in Alfred Ainger's Lectures and Essays (1905) -- to a 'defiant rearguard' in the ranks of the neo-classicists. Donald Davie took up the latter position in the 1950s and again in The Eighteenth-Century English Hymn (1993), arguing that Cowper laboured as a neo-classical poet in the shadow of Pope and should not be read as a mediocre Wordsworth. Davie makes a good case for linking Cowper to the 'Augustans' -- e.g. Goldsmith, Prior, and Johnson -- and locates him in a tradition of cultural 'sobriety'. His moralism and 'plain style' was in step with the long-established Augustan ideals of the age. Thus Cowper's deference to Homer, whom he called in a letter of 1786, 'the best poet that ever lived for many reasons, but for none more than for that majestic plainness that distinguishes him from all others'. Clearly, a strong didactic focus runs through Cowper's writing (the correspondence as much as the verse), and a concern with, and flair for, classical form -- not to mention the almost de rigueur Augustan attempt at classical translation -- which shows he shared the same intellectual milieu as Dryden and Pope. Far from auguring a new artistic movement, Cowper's writing, says critic Marshall Brown, is 'that of a problem-ridden, moody latecomer'.

Understanding Cowper as a neo-classical poet is not j! ust a hallmark of recent literary criticism, however. Yet, Cowper is not simply a late version of Pope. His self-revelatory and insecure writing repeatedly jeopardises his neo-classical aesthetic. At the heart of his poetry, contends Vincent Newey, lies the individual, tortured consciousness at odds with a hostile world that would soon become a central Romantic figure. 'Not without cause', writes Newey in Cowper's Poetry (1982), 'did Coleridge name him "the best of modern poets"'; not for nothing did Wordsworth value Cowper's passionate fondness for natural objects and his 'chaste' descriptive diction. Cowper's mature poetry resembles Wordsworth's. 'He knows', argues Patricia Spacks in The Poetry of Vision (1967) 'how to use convention as a mode of expressing intense personal feeling.' Spacks, as the title of her book shows, implies that Cowper is best understood in relation to those contemporaries and immediate predecessors (such as Thomson, Collins, and Smart) who were likewise preoccupied with ways of 'seeing' and 'imagining' the world and 'Nature'.

Newey's masterly reappraisal shows how Cowper foreshadowed the familiar predicament of 'modern man' and the 'Romantics'. Cowper's poems, he argues, reflect the sense of fragmentation and isolation experienced and described by many artists at the end of the eighteenth century. He makes a good case for Cowper as a 'modern' because of the psychological, self-revelatory character of his poems. Newey notes how Cowper's contemporary reviewers simultaneously p! aid close attention to the autobiographical/confessional element of his poems and emphasised his 'Romantic' qualities -- feelings and imagination, nature and mankind. Nothing, says Newey, heralds as strongly as Cowper's poetry '[...] the emergence of the cut-off individual actively involved in the problems of his own existence [...]'.

Meanwhile, political principles and linguistic concerns are key to Tim Fulford's examination of Cowper's 'Politics of Nature' in The Task and 'Politics of Trees' (in 'Yardley Oak'). Cowper, argues Fulford in Landscape, Liberty, and Authority (1996), developed Thomson's critique of the endless extension of Court patronage over the land. He highlights Cowper's ideological promotion of William Pitt and the 'Country Party' in The Task, and shows how independence was a necessary stand for the retired poet. Fulford maintains -- as William Gilpin, Wordsworth, and Coleridge knew -- that Cowper's was an important model since it made retirement a critique both of London politics and of the contemporary country gentry. Fulford's work complements Richard Feingold's Nature and Society (1978). David Perkins ('Cowper's Hares', in Robert DeMaria, British Literature 1640-1789 (1999)) argues Cowper's poetry represents a disciplinary 'attempt [à la Foucault] to reprove and repress the berserk potentialities of human nature'.

However, the notion of Cowper as a 'transitional' poet between a so-called 'Augustan' and 'Romantic Age' endures, even when he is expropriated -- e.g. in Maximilian Novak's Eighteenth-Century Literature (1983) -- to the so-called 'Age of Sensibility'. Further scholarly work on Cowper is anticipated in the bicentennial year of his death. Charles Ryskamp and James King's! edition of Cowper's letters (1979-86) contains 1306 letters. The standard edition of Cowper's poems is by John Baird and Ryskamp (1980-95). Important collections of 'Cowperiana' are at Princeton University's N.C. Hannay Collection, Yale University's Osborn Collection, the Bodleian Library, and Olney.